What sweetener is used in making a scratch Old Fashioned?

A scratch Old Fashioned traditionally emphasizes the classic and original methods that were used to create this iconic cocktail. The use of a sugar cube aligns with the cocktail's historical roots, as it allows bartenders to control the muddling process effectively. When a sugar cube is used, it can be muddled with bitters and a splash of water or citrus essence to create a rich and textured base for the drink.

Using a sugar cube also contributes to the cocktail’s texture and mouthfeel, allowing the flavors to develop more fully as the sugar dissolves during the preparation. This method provides an authentic experience that is appreciated by cocktail enthusiasts who favor traditional preparation techniques.

Whereas alternatives like simple syrup, honey, or brown sugar may offer sweetness, they do not incorporate the same tactile experience or historical context associated with the use of a sugar cube in an Old Fashioned. Sugar cubes have been the standard sweetener in Old Fashioneds for generations, serving as a link to the cocktail's origin.